Directional Failure Index

CWE-Trace framework reveals LLM vulnerability detection is calibration without comprehension

Researchers introduce CWE-Trace, a benchmark of 834 manually curated Linux kernel samples across 74 CWEs with strict temporal splits to prevent data contamination, used to evaluate 8 vanilla LLMs and 15 LoRA fine-tuned variants on vulnerability detection. Key findings: data contamination provides no measurable advantage (84% of nominally contaminated samples carry no usable memorization signal), and backbone directional priors dominate fine-tuning — models exhibit stable systematic failure modes that resist correction. The best binary detection score reaches only 52.1% (barely above chance) and exact CWE classification Top-1 accuracy stays below 1.3%, indicating fine-tuning shifts output distributions without instilling genuine security reasoning. The work introduces two diagnostic metrics (Directional Failure Index and Hierarchical Distance and Direction) and concludes that detection capability and security understanding are decoupled in current LLMs.