the-illusion-of-robustness-aggregate-accuracy-hides-prediction-flips-under-task-irrelevant-context-0e8daca8·1 events·first seen Aliases: The Illusion of Robustness: Aggregate Accuracy Hides Prediction Flips under Task-Irrelevant Context
A new arXiv paper demonstrates that state-of-the-art LLMs appear robust to task-irrelevant context at the aggregate level, but this stability conceals significant per-example prediction flips. Even semantically meaningless pseudo-words prepended to benchmark questions can shift model predictions on a subset of examples, with gains and losses roughly canceling out in aggregate. The instability is modulated by context type, length, test-time compute, and model development stage, and the affected examples are largely model-specific. The authors argue this reveals 'tail risks' hidden by standard aggregate accuracy metrics, motivating per-example reliability evaluation.